I recorded 5 tracks using various amplifiers (with the same direct recorded guitar track). The results were terrible. All kinds of yucky tones and weird phase issues.
But, if I physically played the parts five times, using the same amps as the previous tracks, the results were much better.
And if I re-amp a direct recorded guitar signal using on-board guitar amp plugins (Guitar Rig, Amplitube, LePou) the results are fine.
I guess this might be obvious to some; I'm kind of a newb at this...but it still was a surprise.
Anyone else have better results re-amping?
Am I doing something obviously wrong?