Hi CUBE -- can you detail your signal path using XLRs? That may be my problem also. From the SM57, I use a XLR to TRS adapter into a mic pre, and from there to the audio interface, etc, it is all TRS. From the audio interface out, I use TRS to XLR adapter to go into the XLR Kemper return input. Maybe there is where the issue is -- I should use the TRS return input instead?
I am thinking -- probably should try going from the SM57 into the mic pres of the audio interface (all XLR), and from the audio interface out to the KPA -- use all TRS. That way, there's no adapters, etc.
BTW, I did profile using only a SM57 with no mic pre or DAW in the path -- just the XLR out of the mic into the Kemper return input XLR. Results were the same. So maybe the XLR input is somehow messed up? I sure hope not ...