Some reasons why the Gemini's popularity is limited:
- It is big and heavy
- The cab sim doesn't work for all kinds of tones and would need integration with the controller/pedalbord so that it can be switched on/off to work in practise. It may however be ok if your playing focuses on just a couple different sounds.
- People haven't developed ears at the back of their knees yet. I totally get the visual appeal of rectangular boxes for stacking in a backline, but why don't someone make rectangular cabinets where the interior can be angled at the musician. The Gemini II is based on a coaxial design and probably has a wider dispersion pattern than most guitar cabs, but on most stages I play the space is so cramped I'd almost have to sit on it. I'd have to slant it 45 degrees or stack it up at chest height. A speaker blowing at my feet will be annoyingly loud for the audience up front long before it is loud enough for me to hear it properly.
For me the 3-dimensional amp-in-the-room-effect has been achieved by using two wedges. Even when daisy-chained on a mono-signal those will do the job when they are aimed at you from different angles. I'm usually standing off to one side of the stage with the monitors pointing at me from the front/side and back/side with both monitors aimed somewhere between me and the center of the stage. Add PureCab and my stage-sound is better than it ever was with traditional amps. I manage with one monitor when the space is limited, and as I use multi-channel wedges (Dynacord) I often take a monitor mix (without guitar) into the second channel and adjust my guitar against that mix with the master volume on the profiler.
All very good points and I get what your saying and maybe the big difference/disconnect here from me and others is in regards to how you actually going to use the Gemini cab. In my case I don't play out and only will play it at home. So the weight issue is of no concern to me since I will not be lugging it around. IF I was playing out I doubt I would want to lug it around at that weight. (Mission on their website says 71 pounds is the weight! Musicians Friend says 51 pounds. Either way thats heavy if your carrying it gig to gig).
I agree changing the voicing of the cab from FRFR to the more GRFR for each separate profile in a set list would be hectic for live use/playing out. Then again for me I will have profiles that are preamp only for GRFR voicing on the Gemini and Merged/Studio profiles for FRFR. Not an issue for me since I am just jamming at home to walk over and turn the Empower Q dial on the Gemini for the correct respective profile.
The cab issue as a backline and being too loud for people up front but not loud enough for you to hear is again valid if your playing out live.
I think I am looking at this from a totally different perspective than those who are professional musicians playing out. I can see now why the Gemini II wouldn't appeal to some using it in a live setting.
Not that the following is directed at you in any way just a couple thoughts in general. For me I personally think its a a very cool idea from Mission to try and incorporate the FRFR and GRFR into one traditional looking cab. If it works its less gear I will have to have. (If I end up not liking the Gemini when it arrives I am going to send it back and get a DXR-10 or CLR AND a separate power amp like the Matrix GT800 and a 2x12 guitar cab. That way all the bases for ME would be covered.) Also with the Gemini the addition of the USB capabilities is a nice plus too. I like the idea of recording direct from the cab into my DAW using the sound card supplied in the Gemini. I assume Mission as a company does product research and frequent the forums and look for solutions to problems/issues/wants people are looking for in their gear. For me it ticks off a lot of the boxes I was looking for. IMO to get a 2x12 stereo FRFR system (from a respected company) in a traditional guitar cab with the FRFR/GRFR flexibility and the USB capabilities seems like a good deal to me at the price point I paid. Who knows I may hate the damn thing when it actually arrives (which could very well happen since I am picky). If so I will fall in line and get the DXR-10 or CLR and join the club with everyone