Thanks everyone for the warm welcome and kind words. This is the first forum I've participated in, primarily because of the positive vibe here. Glad some people have enjoyed the profiles. I definitely want to get better at creating them...
I LOVE my BlackJack, and IMHO that amp is a 5-star amp, but I noticed the voting/rating my profiles got were more like 3-4 stars...which means I need to get better at profiling.
I don't think you should worry - a lot of the files people rave about and give high stars leave me kind of cold....lots and lots of high gain stuff that to me sounds like the 50 profiles I just deleted. So far I just have profiled one amp and it got 3 stars. I think, and to my ears it sounds just like the amp itself. It is a very dry profile ie no post adding of reverb, delay etc etc which lots of profiles seem to do. Other people will add a different cab as well, and these are the profiles that seem to get the plaudits.
I do think there are best ways to profile and until I learn these I won't be selling any amps, but getting 5 stars won't be part of the decision process. As HK said the stars isn't about the profiling itself - we have no idea what the amp sounds like 99% of the time. And when people start putting drives in front or in the loop it becomes even less about the amp itself.
I have also wondered if people are totally honest in what they say regarding the amps. I think this is a good forum, but as it grows I wonder if we'll get people playing the forum fame game and being creative with their descriptions in the rig exchange. For example I have 2 Trainwreck type amps here, a Komet and a Red Iron Trex. I bet I can find real Trainwreck clips somewhere and get one of my amps to within 95%. Now, if I was to say it was a real 'wreck and I'd had chance to spend time with it, only a very few people would be able to question that. And, I'm sure no one would be able to say it doesn't sound like a Trainwreck. And, I'm sure it would get more downloads and stars than if it was labelled just a clone. A bit of an extreme example maybe but you get my point....
Btw one of the amps I have to profile is a Lucky 7 - the little brother of your Blackjack! Great amps....
.