Display MorePlease help me understand better. Let's say you have a Power KPA. And, you have hundreds of (coming up on 600 myself) mind blowing amp profiles.
Why try to simulate a 4 speaker cab through a single speaker CLR?
Why not find a cab that sounds great with an amp profile that you like (without the cab simulation)?
If you are going direct to a PA or studio recording, the cab simulation seems critical.
I have tried a Mesa cab and a Fender Hot Rod Deluxe cab. I haven't been able to try a CLR yet. But, it seems to me that it wouldn't necessarily sound better. It would probably sound closer to the simulated cab. But, unless it was a 1x12 cab, I just don't understand why I'd want to try to emulate the cab sound through a CLR.
?
We're basically talking about two different things here.
A guitar cab has got a very specific sound character, by which it's wanted. By swithing cabs using a real amp you can easily realize that the most part of the rig's sonic signature comes from the cab itself.
A guitar amp *needs* a cab with a personality to express the sounds we have learned to love. The cab is part of the amp's sound.
The specificity with a digital simulator is that the sound personality is already written in the patches/profiles (how well, depends on the simulator's quality). When you use a profile, the cab signature is already present.
At this stage, if you amplify it with a further guitar cab, it would be as if you mic'ed your real cab and sent the mic signal to another guitar cab rather than to PA.
It's not a matter of how many loudspeaker the original cab has, but of the ability to faightful reproduce that sound. That's why a good PA or a linear cab are many users' choice.
Keep on mind that onstage, you can have a wall of 4x12s but you usually put one mic in front of *one* cone... This is what arrives at audience, and what usually ends up in a record.
OTOH, you might want to kill the cab simulator in the KPA and use a guitar cab. If the resulting sound makes you happy, you're done! But all your sounds will gravitate around your real cab's signature, and won't generally be faithful to the profiles' original sounds.
How much this is an issue solely depends on user's needs and preferences. What matters most IMO is that we know what we do, and don't harm anyone