"Normal PLAYING (on your guitar) doesn't provide enough isolated upper mids/highs for the most accurate refinement."
Ah, I see. Yes, I totally agree with you on that. On refining we should play all that we want to meet again later in the profiles. And playing isolated and extremley dynamic high end seems to help a lot.
Also on what you said about the upper mids and hights I totally agree with you. If you compare my raw profile (track 2) and the one that I tweaked (track 3) you see that I tend to add too much of high end. I guess this is because I monitored it with the 700 Watt RCF NX-SMA12 set at normal "room" level in my appartment. At these low volumes they seem to swallow a bit too much treble. So I dialled in even more just to compensate... But when I turned the RCFs louder just for a test I always thought it is a bit too bright. You can see this too if you look at how the same track taken DI from the KPA without the RCFs (track 7) is even more brighter. And the bright part of the signal is what emphasizes this "metal ambience".
If you listen to the raw DI signal (track 7 ) you also find the metal ambience sound there. In a way it is all too logical: an electric guitar is basically just a block of wood with steel wires - no wonder it sounds "metallic" if you rub it. But in the REFERENCE Champ mic recording (Track 1) this is weaker and it all sounds smoother again - the tube amp seems to even that out by just allowing not too few and not too much of the high end signal. That's how the engineers meticulously made it, when they designed the circuit. So it is not a "fault" of the KPA but it is a consequence of the ability to dial in too much high end in the digital world. This is something I have to get accustomed too. So the key question seems to me to find the right balance for the high end.
BTW: especially the comparison between the conservative microfone recording (track 1) and and the raw, unedited profile of the same amp (track 2) is really stunning to me. They are so close, that's scary! I checked several times if I did not make a mystake and saved the mic file as a Kemper file - no I did not!!!