Try this:
1. Select a profile with the general feel you're after, but a bit lower gain
2. Set clean sens in the input section so the input LED barely lights yellow, never red, leave distorted sens at 0
3. Put a Green Screamer in one of the stomp slots before the amp, drive = 1.0 / tone = -2.2 / volume = 1.0
4. In the amp block set bias to 3.3
5. In the tonestack section set highs to -1.5 (I often have to reduce bass as well on most profiles, depends on your FRFR)
6. In the cab section set high shift to -0.1
7. Add an analog delay with mix = 43% / delay = 370ms / bandwidth = 3.5 / center freq = -1.5 / duck = 2
8. Add some reverb (I usually go for small room), mix = 50% / reverb time = 2.2s / damping = 5 / predelay = 75ms / bandwidth = 3.5 / center freq = -1.5 / duck = 0
How does it sound now? Let me know