No problem. There have been groups of more people (than the ones being in a band together) being unanimously wrong.
Or a whole lot of forumers apparently
... seriously, that's some strange logic here. Here's another (more accurate?) one:
- Fact 1: a tube amp sound different when it's mic'd, whatever the mic(s) and the preamp used.
- Fact 2: Kemper is profiling a mic'd amp
- Conclusion: using KPA cannot sound the same than a tube amp that is not mic'd, that's not the purpose, but can (exactly, and that's a wonderful device for that!) sound like a mic'd tube amp.
So yes, me and my band members are preferring the pure tone of a tube amp that is not mic'd. And I think we're a lot feeling that way in real life.
Oh, and telling us we're wrong is kinda insulting also: if it works for the tone you're after, great. But not considering that not everyone is looking for the same thing tonewise and that depending on that and on the genre it may differs from one band to another is kind of a strange reasoning don't you think?